As Eleonore Stump so carefully and rightly states, “there is no one orthodox interpretation of the doctrine of the atonement and no one universally agreed upon interpretation of the Eucharist.” Nonetheless, “the general Christian consensus includes the conviction that something about this rite makes a powerful connection between those participating in it and the passion and death of Christ” (Locating Atonement, pp 209, 210). It is this connection that I seek to bring out in what follows.
The Communal Nature of the Holy Eucharist
The Holy Eucharist is a communion with God and with one another. As a corporate activity, the Holy Eucharist is a response of thanksgiving for the work of redemption that Christ achieved for his Church. Because it is corporate, our orientation is not merely vertical as we individually look up to Christ in thanksgiving, but also horizontal and communal as we collectively look out to one another in love. As such, our personal standing with God is not the sole focus of the Holy Eucharist; our standing with one another is also in view. It is by the “one loaf of bread” and the “blood of Christ” that we are united to Christ and to one another (1 Cor 10:17; Eph 2:12-15).
Participating in the Holy Eucharist, therefore, while knowingly experiencing estrangement from other members of our spiritual family would be an instance of partaking in an “unworthy manner” (1 Cor 11:27-33). To be sure, the abuse at Corinth was in failing to “discern the body of Christ” (1 Cor 11:29), which involved a disregard for other members of their community. To depreciate those who are sanctified by Christ is to take what is holy and treat it as if it were profane. The Apostle Paul’s charge to “examine” ourselves first (1 Cor 11:28) involves, at least, evaluating our solidarity (cf., 1 Cor 10:16-17) as reflected in the ways we relate to and treat other members of Christ’s body.
Collectively remembering and partaking of Christ’s broken body and shed blood (1 Cor 11:24-25) unites us in a number of ways. The Holy Eucharist shows our common need for a final and sufficient atonement for sins. It manifests our common status as undeserved recipients of his costly grace and it demonstrates our common confession of Christ as the communal Host for the meal.
The Sacramental Nature of the Holy Eucharist
To appreciate the sacramental nature of the Holy Eucharist, it is important to recall the backstory from Scripture. Passover is the commemoration and celebration of Israel’s deliverance from slavery to Egypt and their freedom as a nation. In the tenth and worst of the plagues on Egypt, God instructed the Israelites to mark the doorposts of their homes with the blood of a slaughtered lamb and, upon seeing this, the spirit of the Lord knew to pass over the first-born in these homes. This led to Pharaoh’s release of the Israelite slaves and to their subsequent freedom. The Passover event was to be celebrated annually by the whole community as a common and unifying experience for the nation. It defined the nation of Israel and fixed their identity as a people chosen by God (Ex 12).
Passover came to mark a season of transitions. The old year transitions to the new (Ex 12:2), from the rainy season/winter to the dry season/summer. The old leaven is cleared out to make way for the new, which symbolically portrays Israel’s transition from bondage to freedom, from death to life (Ex 12:15-20). Doorposts marked with the sacrificial blood of a lamb show the transition from God’s judgment outside the threshold to his life-preserving favor inside. All these things, and more, are illustrated in the Holy Eucharist.
Jesus celebrated the Passover Meal with his disciples (Lk 22:15-20) and no doubt the images of the first Passover were present to them. Jesus leverages the bread and the wine to portray his impending death. Just as Israel was saved from slavery in Egypt by the death of a Passover lamb (Ex 12:21), so believers in Christ are saved from slavery to sin by the death of our Passover Lamb (Jn 1:29; 1 Cor 5:7; Rev 5:12). As with Israel’s Passover lamb, Jesus too was without blemish or defect (Ex 12:5; 1 Pt 1:19). The disciples all drank from one cup and ate from one loaf emphasizing their solidarity and identity as God’s people (Lk 22:17). Through these events and symbols, the whole community experiences a common and unifying spiritual experience in the celebration of the Holy Eucharist, our Passover. Moreover, the Supper binds us, not just to all those present to us, but also to the invisible Church of God, our eschatological community whose presence we will one day enjoy. In this solemn act of eating the bread and drinking from the cup, we declare our transition from death to life eternal, from estrangement to adoption, from solitude to solidarity with the people of God, and from bondage in sin to freedom in Christ.
How, then, might this spiritual experience in the Holy Eucharist be known? It is not in the administration of the elements alone, nor the mere mental recollection of all that Christ has done, to which the elements point. Neither is Christ’s presence localized in the bread or the wine, just as he is not present in the words of Scripture. Instead, we commune with and are nourished by the redemptive presence of Christ when the Holy Spirit unites our faith with those acts of eating and drinking. When we consume the symbols of Christ’s body and blood our union with Christ and with one another is both manifest and renewed. The repeated experience of the Holy Eucharist also elicits perseverance of the saints as God’s Spirit makes us aware, again and again, of the depth and extent of God’s love shown to us in the cross of Christ. In all these ways and more, the Holy Eucharist is God’s way of mediating his grace to us and in us as he continually transforms us after his image.
Insofar as we eat the bread and drink the cup in faith, then we not only remember the benefits of Christ’s death, but we also reenact our original surrender to God’s irresistible love as shown in Christ’s death (Rom 5:8). Although this reenactment is a historical reminder, it takes place in the current unfolding of our lives and serves to strengthen our resolve to love Christ more. All that remains is heartfelt gratitude (hence “eucharist” = “thanksgiving”) for so great a salvation that is offered by our Passover Lamb of God. As a people chosen by God’s sheer mercy and grace we proclaim our transition from death to life until one day he comes to feast with us in eternity (Lk 22:18; 1 Cor 11:26; Rev 19:9).